Most individuals love studying, whether or not they’re avid readers getting by 50 to 100 books a yr or extra sporadic readers who dabble with two or three actually nice novels.
However one factor readers don’t agree on is which format – Kindle, library borrowing, looking Waterstones each three days – is finest.
Audiobooks are notably controversial, as some consider listening to somebody learn a e-book aloud isn’t the identical as ‘actual’ studying.
Goodreads, a platform utilized by e-book lovers to document the books they need to learn and the books they’ve learn, doesn’t have a separate audiobook part. When you’ve got listened to an audiobook, you may merely add it to your ‘learn’ record, however ought to audiobooks be thought-about as such?
Frances Norman, an avid TikTok user who is part of the community known as ‘BookTok’, where people share their reviews of books, update each other on their reading goals, and discuss their favourites, says that they absolutely should.
‘When you listen to an audiobook you take in the book word for word as the author wrote it,’ she said. ‘There’s no reason to say that you haven’t read a book because you listened to the audiobook. In fact, it would be misleading.
‘The purpose of a book is to tell a story, to construct characters and a setting and impart a certain atmosphere, emotions, and message to the audience.
‘An audiobook can do all of these things just as well – sometimes better – than a physical book and shouldn’t be discounted because of ableist rhetoric.’
Others on BookTok agree, with many videos commenting on the fact some people believe that they haven’t ‘read’ as much as they say since many of the books were consumed in audiobook format.
We put the question out on Twitter, to which journalist Katie Williams said: ‘Yes definitely [they should]! Many people find it difficult to actually read but an audio book allows them to consume it in a way that works for them.’
Kelsie Colclough agrees: ‘A number of us wrestle to search out time to take a seat down and revel in a e-book, however we are able to play an audiobook as we do different issues. Additionally, I get movement illness after I learn within the automotive or on the practice – audiobooks are a godsend.’
‘Something that will increase how a lot we learn is an efficient factor, in my e-book,’ she provides.
Others notice that audiobooks are various for people who find themselves very busy and might’t carve out time to learn.
‘As a busy mother or father of younger kids, and a enterprise founder, the [audiobook] format makes books accessible to me on the go. I squeeze them in on the college run, and between purchasers, in a manner that I don’t with a paperback,’ EJ Trivett tells us.
The overall consensus was that as you’re nonetheless consuming the story written by the creator, it doesn’t matter how it was consumed.
As JJ Barnes places it: ‘Audiobooks are nonetheless books.’
Moreover, audiobooks are very helpful for accessibility functions. For the visually impaired, audiobooks are the first option to eat written materials, and for neuro-divergent folks or these with disabilities that impression their skill to learn a paperback or hardback e-book, it’s an important choice to have.
Frances explains: ‘To not think about listening to an audiobook as studying is an inherently ableist perspective.
‘Audiobooks make studying accessible not solely to visually impaired folks, but in addition folks with psychological disabilities and neurodiversities.
‘As somebody with ADHD, I wrestle with a diversified consideration span and audiobooks enable me to learn while additionally occupying myself in one other manner, which helps me maintain my thoughts centered on the e-book.’
On Twitter, a number of feedback made the identical argument about accessibility, declaring that saying audiobooks will not be a ‘actual’ manner of studying may be very invalidating.
Olivia Day stated: ‘I get the argument that they aren’t “actual” books, as they’re very totally different actions, however think about telling a blind one that depends on audiobooks that their studying was someway invalid? Audiobooks are actually essential for accessibility.’
Rebekah Conway, who’s writing her debut novel now and can be offering an audio model when it’s launched, provides: ‘It’s essential to make having fun with the written phrase as accessible as doable.’
‘You wouldn’t (or shouldn’t) inform a braille reader they didn’t “really learn” the e-book as a result of they used braille to learn it as a substitute of studying the phrases, so why achieve this for audiobooks?’ says BBC Content material Creator and YouTuber Stephanie Symington.
Ruby Punt on Twitter suggested that literature has moved away from the traditional written word and can incorporate a variety of formats.
For instance, rap music stems from the phrase ‘rhythm and poetry’ and many rap songs have been considered to be poems in their own right, while musician Bob Dylan won the Nobel Prize for Literature.
Punt said: ‘It just shows how consumption of literature has moved away from physical texts.’
But, despite many convincing arguments for audiobooks, people still disagree. Phoebe Dodds said the two (audiobooks and books) were not comparable in any way.
‘I equate audiobooks with podcasts – maybe easier than actual reading. There are pros and cons to both, but I wouldn’t say it’s accurate to count audiobooks as books you’ve “read”,’ she explains.
Another person said there should be a distinction between the two: ‘I’d make the distinction of having listened [to an audiobook] vs. have read [a book] because I think the experience between the two is distinct enough.’
‘But, it’s not a distinction to scoff at nor one that implies one method is superior over the other, just acknowledging that they’re different.’
Though the debate continues, it is clear that most people love listening to audiobooks and that it is their preferred method of consuming books for a variety of reasons.
And, regardless of where you stand, if you love to ‘read’ books, whatever format you choose simply has to be the right one for you.
Do you have a story to share?
Get in touch by emailing MetroLifestyleTeam@Metro.co.uk.
window.fbApi = (function ()
var fbApiInit = false; var awaitingReady = ;
var notifyQ = function ()
var i = 0,
l = awaitingReady.length;
for (i = 0; i < l; i++)
var ready = function (cb)
var checkLoaded = function ()
window.fbAsyncInit = function ()
fbApiInit = true;
'ready' : ready,
'loaded' : checkLoaded
if ( window.fbApi && window.fbApi.loaded() ) return;
var d = document,
id = 'facebook-jssdk';
var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s);
js = d.createElement(s);
js.id = id;
js.async = true;
js.src = "https://connect.facebook.net/en_US/sdk.js";
if ('object' === typeof metro)
window.addEventListener('metro:scroll', injectFBSDK, once: true);
window.addEventListener('DOMContentLoaded', injectFBSDK, once: true);